This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

FREE SHIPPING to the United States & Canada

Expert in vintage costume jewelry from the 1920s, 1930s, 1940s & 1950s

Vintage starfish brooch by Alice Caviness
Back of vintage starfish brooch
Dazzling vintage starfish brooch & earrings set
Starfish earrings
Matching earrings
Earring backs
Maker's mark

Diamanté & Gold Starfish Brooch by Alice Caviness


MAKER: Alice Caviness

SIZE: 3" diameter brooch; 1 1/4" x 7/8" earrings

CONDITION: Excellent

DATE: c.1956

MARKS: Brooch: "ALICE CAVINESS" in block letters on oval cartouche. Earrings: none.


This vintage starfish brooch is bold and dazzling. The aurora borealis diamantés in the gold-tone setting take on the color of the metal, catch the light, and seem to dance. The brooch with a roll-over safety clasp reflects the hue of the garment it’s pinned to. Although women in the 1950s typically wore matching sets of jewelry, you don’t have to do that. Just add gold studs or hoops. Consider these ear clips, each shaped like one of the creature’s arms, a bonus. This jewel is versatile and guaranteed to get you noticed! What an imaginative adornment for a bride’s hair or veil!

FREE SHIPPING to the United States and Canada

[{"variant_id":"44745971728660" , "metafield_value":""}]

Diamanté & Gold Starfish Brooch by Alice Caviness

$395.00 USD
Why Buy Vintage Costume Jewelry?

One reason is that it’s environmentally friendly. Resale fashion and vintage jewelry has become a preferred sustainable and affordable shopping choice by today’s discerning fashion and eco-conscious consumer.

Another major reason is the quality. Although vintage costume jewelry was made for all levels of the marketplace – from dime stores to high-end fashion boutiques and jewelry stores – you will find only the best pieces here. They were well-designed and carefully made to last. The manufacturers represented here used only the finest materials – glass stones and beads from Bohemia, Austria, and France, and faux pearls from France and Japan. Settings were primarily sterling silver, gold-filled, or base metals heavily plated with gold, silver, or rhodium. Stones were hand-set, and pieces were hand-finished.

The northeastern part of the U.S. was the center of the industry, with the largest companies located in Providence, Rhode Island by the end of World War II. During the Depression, the quality of costume pieces climbed to new levels when many jewelers and craftsmen had to switch to this segment of the industry. In addition, it attracted many skilled workers who fled the political situation in Europe for the U.S. For these reasons, designs and manufacturing techniques rivaled those employed in the making of fine jewelry.

A third reason to buy costume jewelry is its uniqueness. Having survived for so many decades in such wonderful condition and having been selected for their aesthetic quality, the pieces you’ll find here are unlikely to be found elsewhere.

True vs Fake - how to shop vintage costume jewelry with confidence

Barbara Schwartz, a noted costume jewelry historian, is the author of "True vs Fake" , an in-depth blog series providing examples of how vintage costume jewelry can be accurately attributed. She also shares tips on how to avoid being duped into buying misidentified vintage costume jewelry.